No Go For HMO's
How the landscape for HMO claims has altered over the years.

We have been approached several times in the recent past to consider claims for clients who own portfolios of HMO’s.
It has long been our view that claims for HMO’s (House’s in Multiple Occupancy) are not possible. Over the years HMRC have issued several updates and have concluded that HMO’s are to be treated as a ‘dwelling-house’ and claims for capital allowances should therefore be refused.
The History
Prior to 2008, claims for HMO’s were very common although were often restricted to the communal areas of the property such as stairs, hallways, shared kitchen, bathrooms and living rooms. This view was clarified by HMRC in Revenue & Customs Brief 66/08 although the guidance did not take in to account the distinction between large style student accommodation and smaller cluster flats or HMO’s.
Two years later, further clarification was provided by Revenue & Customs Brief 45/10. This brief stated:
Returning to the example of student accommodation at paragraph four above, HMRC have concluded that the better view is that each flat in multiple occupation comprises a dwelling-house, given that the individual study bedrooms alone would not afford the occupants 'the facilities required for day-to-day private domestic existence'. In other words, the communal kitchen and lounge are also part of the dwelling-house. The common parts of the building block (such as the common entrance lobby, stairs or lifts) would not, however, comprise a 'dwelling-house'.
Following this brief, claims in relation to HMO’s were limited to the common parts of the property such as hallways, stairwell and landings and were consequently quite small. Claims were still very worthwhile where clients’ owned a number of such properties, or where the property included an element of genuine commercial use, such as an HMO above a shop.
Several years ago, HMRC updated their Internal Manual at CA11520 to state:
There is no definition of “dwelling-house” in these Parts of CAA01 and so the term takes its ordinary meaning. A dwelling-house is a building, or a part of a building; its distinctive characteristic is its ability to afford to those who use it the facilities required for day-to-day private domestic existence. In most cases there should be little difficulty in deciding whether or not particular premises comprise a dwelling-house, but difficult cases may need to be decided on their particular facts. In such cases the question is essentially one of fact.
It also includes the following conclusion:
Claims relating to Houses in Multiple Occupancy:
We are aware that some taxpayers have submitted claims for plant and machinery allowances in respect of shared parts of houses in multiple occupation (such as hallways, stairs, landings, attics and basements within the houses). They contend that these shared areas are not part of the dwelling-house and that allowances are therefore available. We disagree with this position. If you come across such a claim, please notify the Capital Allowances single point of contact for your area.
You will notice that there is a window to make a claim as per the guidance in Revenue & Customs Brief 66/08 for properties purchased after 29 December 2008 but before 22 October 2010.
Update
Back in July (2025), HMRC updated CA11520 to include a much more descriptive definition of what constitutes a ‘Dwelling-House’ and includes examples of the differing types of properties.
For more information, please see the updated guidance
here.
Conclusion
- Claims for HMO’s are now even more likely to be refused by HMRC following the most recent update to CA11520.
- The guidance in CA11520 gives clarity on claims for categories of properties which were often viewed as areas of grey. These include Serviced Apartments, blocks of flats, supported housing, sheltered accommodation etc.
- Claims for genuine commercial premises such as Nursing Homes, Hotels, B&B’s and Prison's, run as a trade and where services are provided, can still be made, as has always been the case.
If you’d like to discuss the recent updates or a specific client scenario, please do call one of the team as we’d be delighted to help.







